Students Are Not Widgets – The Chronicle can’t stop whoring itself.

I use AI for research, but it also removes some of the most colorful language that I am prone to use. I read an article in the Houston Chronicle and felt they were just being their normal whorish selves. Promoting something they know nothing about but must make whoever pays them, via ads or however, happy.

Research suggests that tests are used to discriminate against minority students. What better way to say black and brown students are stupid than by pointing at tests where they rank lower?

While reading the Houston Chronicle, one sentence caught my attention. “Some Democratic lawmakers from Houston, including the incoming House speaker, Senfronia Thompson, have said schools in their area have improved from its takeover.” I read the article as a case for keeping test scores at the center of how Texas judges its schools. I taught school, and the growing emphasis on getting students to pass a test was one reason I decided to leave. Houston Chronicle

My first thought was about the kids in those classrooms. In a crowded classroom at a low-income school, some students may read well below grade level and others well above it. Their IQ scores might range from the 80s to the 140s. Then hand their teacher a set of scores from a test in May and tell her those numbers show how well she taught. How in the hell is she supposed to reach every one of those kids in a crowded classroom when the district expects most of them to clear the same bar by the end of the year? Maybe the state would rather chop them up, make a stew, and grade the stew when it’s cooked.

I don’t know what every school does now. When I taught, my students had been away from school for two and a half months, and the district didn’t test them when they came back to see where they were starting. A score at the end of the year can tell me how a student did that day. To tell me how far that student came while I had them, you have to know what they could do when they walked through my door.

I could raise a score without cheating or teaching a kid any more biology. Tell the students to put a B in every multiple-choice blank they would otherwise leave empty. On the released spring 2024 STAAR Biology test, B was right on 11 of 34 single-answer multiple-choice questions. A student who picked up three points that way could go from 11 points and failing to 14 points and passing. The state counts one more student who passed. The student knows exactly as much biology as before. STAAR answer key · Texas Education Agency scoring table

Researchers have found that earlier test scores can help estimate how much a teacher contributed to later test performance. The American Statistical Association points out that those estimates can also pick up differences in class size, outside tutoring, and which students a teacher gets. In one study of grades three through eight, the same teachers ranked very differently depending on whether researchers used fall or spring scores. In another study, a teacher’s effect on whether kids showed up, stayed out of trouble, and moved on to the next grade told researchers more about who would finish high school than that teacher’s effect on test scores. One test is too little evidence to decide how well somebody taught. Kane and Staiger · American Statistical Association · Atteberry and Mangan · C. Kirabo Jackson

I worked with some teachers whose judgment I wouldn’t have trusted to rate somebody else’s classroom. Some of the people the district used to evaluate teachers came out of that same pool. Giving somebody a form to fill out doesn’t make them a better judge of whether a kid is learning.

I also believe testing can become a way to separate white kids from Black and Mexican American kids. One way that happens is through the language of the test. A child who hears English at home closer to the English used on the test starts with an advantage in understanding what’s being asked. A child can know how to solve a math problem and still get tripped up trying to read it. Jamal Abedi and Carol Lord found that eighth graders did a little better when they simplified the wording of math questions while keeping the math the same. Research on African American English has also found that differences between the English children use at home and the English they encounter in school texts can make learning to read those texts harder. Abedi and Lord · Washington and Seidenberg

In 2025, 58 percent of white fifth graders in Texas met grade level on STAAR math, compared with 42 percent of Hispanic students and 33 percent of Black students. Asian students scored higher still, at 81 percent. Those numbers show who cleared the state’s cutoff. The scores alone can’t tell us how much of the gap came from language, poverty, or what children had the opportunity to learn. When Texas attaches consequences to those scores, the gaps affect real children and the schools they attend. Texas Academic Performance Report

We did fine at West Oso before Texas decided it needed a statewide test to tell us how we were doing. My youngest brother Joel was valedictorian and went to Princeton. Texas started its statewide basic-skills tests in 1980 and began using test results to rate campuses and districts in the 1990s. In 2002, George W. Bush signed No Child Left Behind. The idea was to make schools show how different groups of students were doing, because an overall average could hide who was being left behind. I understand the reason for making that information public. I object to what Texas has come to do with those scores. Texas Education Agency history · Texas accountability manual · No Child Left Behind fact sheet

My father belonged to the American G.I. Forum. Years later, the G.I. Forum and other plaintiffs went to court over Texas’s use of the TAAS exam to deny students a diploma. The federal judge found a substantial adverse impact on minority students when they first took the exam. He still ruled for Texas, finding that the test served legitimate educational goals. The State of Texas had the legal right to keep using the test. I still think it was wrong to make a diploma depend so heavily on it. G.I. Forum v. Texas Education Agency

Senfronia Thompson praised the students at North Forest High School when the school earned an A, up from a D in 2023. They deserve the credit she gave them. The Chronicle gave Thompson one sentence without naming a school or quoting her directly. It also left out what HISD was spending at North Forest. State and local spending directly at North Forest rose from $11,631 per student in the first year of the takeover to $15,746 in the second. That’s $4,115 more per student. I’m glad those kids got more resources. They should have had them all along. The Chronicle gives the takeover credit for results it hasn’t shown required replacing the elected board. HISD’s North Forest report · TEA spending report, 2024 · TEA spending report, 2025

When I taught, my classroom was the dumping ground for the kids everybody called “bad.” I took a day off once. A few weeks later, the substitute who covered my class came by to see me. He told me he couldn’t figure out how I handled those students. That’s a true story.

I was happy if I convinced a kid to stay in school, graduate, and become a productive member of society. If that student went on to work as a janitor, I was proud of them. Some became police officers, some became lawyers, and who knows what else. How many other professions have people come back years later just to thank you? Sometimes that’s when you find out what the work you did in a classroom meant to somebody.

I consider that classroom a success. Houston should keep putting money into schools like North Forest and return control of HISD to the people who elect its board. The state has put far more weight on test scores than the evidence justifies.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha


Scroll to Top