
Ken Paxton is dropping lawsuits, but he still has time to come after Houston. He abandoned his efforts to shut down FIEL Houston and Annunciation House, organizations that serve immigrants. His office offered no explanation for those withdrawals. Houston, however, remains worth pursuing. texastribune.org
My opinion: Paxton knows who will bend the knee. He knows Houston already backed down once. He knows John Whitmire spent decades surviving in a Legislature controlled by Republicans. And I suspect he recognizes the difference between a politician who wants to win a fight and one who wants permission to avoid it.
We already called Whitmire a sheep. When commentators described Republican senators as sheep under Dan Patrick, I asked where that left Whitmire, a Democrat who retained his committee chairmanship under Patrick. That was my judgment about his political behavior. Moving from the Senate to City Hall apparently did not cure the habit of looking toward Austin before deciding what Houston deserves. El Tejano “Meme”
April gave Paxton a reason to expect another retreat. Council approved restrictions on HPD’s cooperation with ICE. Abbott threatened $114 million in public safety funding, and the city rescinded them. On November 13, Paxton sought summary judgment in the existing Houston case, challenging Whitmire’s November 6 executive order. Whitmire has vowed to fight. This time, Houston deserves to see that promise carried through. houstonchronicle.com
Meanwhile, the mayor’s administration is fighting the council members trying to strengthen his own policy. Alejandra Salinas, Edward Pollard and Tiffany Thomas proposed putting the restrictions into an ordinance, with additional reporting requirements. City Attorney Arturo Michel blocked it, citing the division between legislative and administrative authority. An ordinance would also make the policy harder for a mayor to reverse alone. houstonchronicle.com
Pollard asked the question any reasonable person would ask. If the proposed restrictions repeat the executive order’s language, how can one be acceptable and the other unlawful? In the council exchange, Michel pointed to different processes and explained that the mayor was willing to take a calculated risk.
Apparently, the mayor can take a calculated risk, but council cannot even take a vote.
Salinas then brought receipts. She quoted Michel’s earlier explanation that council could establish policies and prescribe the framework under which departments operate. She asked him to reconcile that position with his new rejection. His answer kept returning to different facts and different circumstances.
Then identify them. Explain precisely what changed. A legal conclusion should survive a council member asking how you reached it.
Instead, the discussion acquired a warning about the Open Meetings Act—and even a “conspiracy element.” Michel said the subject was not on the agenda. Salinas asked for a public hearing, and Whitmire repeatedly offered access to the attorney without agreeing to the public hearing she requested.
If the subject requires its own agenda item, put it on the agenda. The cure for an improperly scheduled discussion should be a properly scheduled discussion.
That is where all the explanations begin to sound like baffling people with bullshit. Different processes. Different facts. Different circumstances. An executive order the mayor can risk issuing, an ordinance council cannot vote on, and questions that suddenly require everyone to stop talking.
Houstonians should not need a law degree to discover who is willing to stand behind their own policy.
Tiffany Thomas put the obligation plainly: “He should spend his political currency on the people of Houston.” After more than fifty years in the Legislature, Whitmire should have enough experience to explain his position publicly and defend it under questioning. houstonchronicle.com
Paxton’s motive is his to explain; Whitmire’s conduct is ours to judge. My judgment is that Paxton sees a familiar opportunity: threaten Houston and wait for its mayor to find an exit.
Houston elected a mayor. It is time Whitmire stopped behaving like MAGA’s sheep.
