How to Make an Excellent School Disappear, à la Miles

The Houston Chronicle, Jolanda Jones, Senfronia Thompson, and others who pushed the takeover all share responsibility for destroying HISD. Will it make a comeback? Will HISD make a comeback? Not while the so-called leaders keep putting their own agendas ahead of the children who attend its schools.

Mike Miles inherited a successful school at Cage Elementary. His administration proceeded to dismantle the community that helped make it successful, then cited declining enrollment as a reason to close its building. That is my assessment of a record that includes academic achievement, families choosing Cage, administrative upheaval, parent protests, and warnings that came years before the closure.

Cage’s success was documented in HISD’s own records. The school earned an A in 2022, before Miles became superintendent. Its 2021–22 demographic report listed 442 students and 86.5% building utilization. Of those students, 224 transferred in from outside its attendance zone. Families were choosing this East End school for their children. resources.finalsite.net

The takeover brought a demand that Cage change how it operated. Its principal opted into Miles’ New Education System-aligned program during summer 2023, but parents said they had no meaningful voice in that decision. During the first week of classes, HISD reassigned Principal Maria Castillo and replaced her with Mary Lou Walter. By September, teachers were being told to embrace the instructional model or face reassignment. Division superintendent Luz Martinez declared: “We are not going back. We are not compromising—we will be NES-aligned.” www.houstonchronicle.com

Parents described what those changes meant for their children. In a September 2023 Chronicle report, Cage parents Thomas Lopez and Spencer Smith said their daughters were losing enthusiasm for school. They objected to a scripted curriculum that restricted teachers’ ability to respond to students’ needs. They loved walking their daughters to their neighborhood school, but were considering other options. www.houstonchronicle.com

One parent warned where this could lead. On September 18, 2023, the Chronicle reported that Mayra Lemus feared the district was pushing teachers and families out, potentially leading to declining enrollment and eventual closure. She urged families to stay. The shared Cage and Project Chrysalis campus already faced at least four teaching vacancies following termination proceedings, a reassignment, and a retirement. Her warning deserves attention now because she made it while the damage was unfolding. www.houstonchronicle.com

The leadership turmoil continued. HISD removed Walter from the principal’s role in November 2023. Lemus told the Chronicle that parents struggled to obtain answers about their children’s education and reported that one parent had withdrawn her son after repeated difficulties arranging a meeting about his grades. Deirdre Riordan became Cage’s principal in December. www.houstonchronicle.com

Enrollment then fell sharply during Miles’ administration. Cage had 418 students in 2022–23, before his arrival, followed by 365 in his first year, 319 in his second, and 310 in 2025–26. Enrollment had been declining earlier, but the school lost almost 26% of its remaining students during those three years. Those figures establish the decline; the contemporary parent accounts help explain why the administration’s decisions deserve scrutiny. txschools.net

The building also had genuine problems, and those belong in the record. HISD’s 2024 bond presentation proposed rebuilding and expanding Cage, describing its condition as beyond normal repair. In 2026, the district instead approved moving Cage into Lantrip, citing enrollment, demographics, funding, and facilities. Cage retained its school identity while losing its own campus. www.houstonpress.com

The unanswered question is how much of Cage’s enrollment loss HISD helped create. A complete answer requires records showing where departing students went and why their families left. But the evidence already available supports a serious charge: Miles’ administration disrupted an established, successful school community, dismissed objections, and later treated the diminished enrollment as a reason to vacate its building.

Families warned HISD about this outcome in 2023. The history of Cage should preserve their warning—and hold the people making the decisions accountable for what followed.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha


Scroll to Top