The Supreme Court Is Bringing Back the Inquisition
Satire

All non-Catholics beware. The Supreme Court is bringing back the Inquisition. Apparently, the Court took one look at 1789 and decided it was still too modern. Catholics might want to keep their baptismal certificates handy, too.
Six of the nine justices are Catholic, including Sonia Sotomayor. I expect her to dissent and ask where the Constitution gives the Supreme Court jurisdiction over a confessional. The majority will cite a fifteenth-century friar and call it originalism. Gallup
Justice Neil Gorsuch was raised Catholic and has attended an Episcopal church. The Court will have to decide whether that counts as a conversion or a change of venue. CNN
The Spanish Inquisition prosecuted baptized Christians accused of heresy. That included converts suspected of still practicing Judaism or Islam in secret. In 1492, the Spanish Crown ordered Jews who kept their faith to leave Spain. Converting could let a family stay, and it also put them under the Inquisition’s jurisdiction. Metropolitan Museum of Art · Universidad Carlos III de Madrid
To force a confession, inquisitors could hoist a prisoner by the wrists with a rope and pulley. A conviction could mean a public whipping, prison, or confiscation of property. Officials read sentences aloud at a public ceremony called an auto de fe. They handed people condemned to die over to the civil authorities, who could burn them at the stake. In Mexico City in 1596, Luis de Carvajal the Younger was condemned to burn for practicing Judaism in secret. Ron E. Hassner · EBSCO · UNAM
I can hear the Puritans of New England insisting they were more civilized. At Salem, the authorities hanged nineteen people accused of witchcraft. The sheriff pressed Giles Corey to death under heavy stones, trying to make him enter a plea. I imagine the Puritans’ brief to the Supreme Court would be short. “Your Honors, we would like credit for doing it without a match.” Peabody Essex Museum · Massachusetts Archives
The first notices will go out to anyone who has ever checked “none” on a form asking for their religion. The clerk will ask whether they meant “none” or “none of your business.” The Court will treat the second answer as a request for oral argument.
Texas will file a brief insisting that the Inquisition be left to the states. A footnote will argue that Texas should get to run it in all fifty.
I can already hear the chief justice at the end of the first hearing. “Go in peace. Your appeal is denied.”




